Post by @paul

Codeberg Status
@codebergstatus @social.anoxinon.de

As you probably noticed, our domain codeberg.org is entirely unreachable.

It was registered with namesilo and entirely disappeared from our account. We're waiting for their customer support to investigate the situation.

No, we didn't forget to renew. There are no suspicious logins in the login history. There is no entry about the situation in the account's domain history.

We'll try setting up a workaround on our codeberg.eu domain ASAP.

Codeberg Status
@codebergstatus @social.anoxinon.de

Update: We have received the confirmation that our domain was suspended and our case got forwarded to the abuse team. We're still waiting for a final decision.

Paul Wilde
@paul
Public en edited

@codebergstatus@social.anoxinon.de oh crap. Suspended?!
I hope this turns out OK!
Think namesilo are an american company... In this current future we are in a situation where you can have been suspended for being anti-AI ("and therefore the enemy!") Which is absolutely crazy.

(I am not saying that is it, but if memory serves, Codeberg has had attacks by far-right extremists before!)

Replying to @paul
🐈‍⬛David Sommerseth
@dazo @infosec.exchange

@paul

NameSilo seems to be an American company, yes. That is one red flag for Europe these days.

But the .org TLD is also managed by Public Interest Registry (PIR), yet another American organisation. And PIR is again under control by Internet Society (ISOC), even yet another American company.

And then it is the organisation with the overseeing the Internet "administration", which TLD providers need to collaborate with - ICANN. Yes, you guessed it right, another American organisation.

So escaping American influence on domains and the Internet is close to impossible. How to "fix" that is an entirely different discussion for a different thread.

@codebergstatus

@dazo@infosec.exchange @paul@paulwilde.uk @codebergstatus@social.anoxinon.de yep, definitely. I try to only pick domain TLDs that are within the control of sensible countries, but I know even then it's not as straightforward

My point here was it seems namesilo are the ones from which the suspension has come. Even so, they could just be handling the abuse reports from random internet people against codeberg.

I dunno, I guess we will see!

Replying to @paul
Codeberg Status
@codebergstatus @social.anoxinon.de

@paul @dazo

While we're not perfectly happy with namesilo for other reasons, suspending a service without double-checking is something that can happen with every company. We once had EU-based Netcup suspend our VPS, too.

Viraptor
@viraptor @cyberplace.social

@codebergstatus
There's unfortunately a reason why MarkMonitor and CSC Corporate Domains exist as a premium service. Their whole thing is that they wouldn't act without contacting a customer first.
@paul @dazo

illiliti
@illiliti @fosstodon.org

@codebergstatus @paul @dazo This is still unacceptable behavior to unilaterally take down a website that basically serves a public interest. Some retaliatory action is clearly warranted.

Stéphane Bortzmeyer
@bortzmeyer @mastodon.gougere.fr

@illiliti @codebergstatus @paul @dazo Nobody took down a website. Namesilo suspended the domain name.

@bortzmeyer@mastodon.gougere.fr @illiliti@fosstodon.org @codebergstatus@social.anoxinon.de @dazo@infosec.exchange and I wonder what effect that would have... 🤔

But let's not argue over the actual words here. We don't even know if it's an attack. It might just have been an admin error or over-active automation system.

illiliti
@illiliti @fosstodon.org

@bortzmeyer @codebergstatus @paul @dazo website got disrupted, that was my point. No need to be picky about words

Cassandrich
@dalias @hachyderm.io

@codebergstatus @paul @dazo While it *shouldn't* be something that can happen without double and triple checking by humans, yes wrongful suspension is something that happens with most service providers.

What's not acceptable though is making the domain just go poof as if it never existed. That is just panic-inducing and unjustifiable. It should show up in the account as suspended/disabled with clear indicators how to remedy the problem. And in the absence of a court order not to allow this, there should always be a path to transfer the domain out to a different registrar if they are no longer willing to host it for whatever policy reason.